Another wonderful week, and a smile

29 October 2022

Our third prime minister in three months took office this week – Italy eat your heart out. A cartoon showed the king meeting Rishi Sunak and saying “One hears that your wife is richer than one’s mama”.

Most of the wealth he shares with his wife comes from her father’s business, Infosys, which was founded by her father in 1981.  While Sunak had to be shown recently how to use a contactless card, his in-laws live a very modest life.  N R Narayana Murthy and his wife Sudha have lived in the same flat for decades and he drives a small car.  The only reported difference in their lifestyles is that their flat is now filled with books and his commitment to philanthropy has come to the fore with his having said “The real power of money is in giving it away”.

No doubt his time at Winchester and Oxford will have cured Sunak of any such nonsense.

To everyone’s great relief, Boris Johnson withdrew from the leadership contest after apparently failing to get enough support, saying “ … in the course of the last days I have sadly come to the conclusion that this would simply not be the right thing to do.”  A new Johnson!   Concerned about “the right thing to do”!  Perhaps leopards do change their spots.  Perhaps pigs will fly.

The only bum note so far is Sunak’s reappointment of Suella Braverman as Home Secretary.  Six days earlier, she was fired from the post for multiple and serious breaches of the ministerial code on the security of market sensitive information.  Although Sunak told parliament she’d declared her error and repented, she actually fessed up only after the cabinet secretary, Simon Case, had challenged her about it.

But let’s give Sunak a clean sheet to start with and see how he deals with all the other problems he’s inherited. 

One of these is the controversial public order bill which will add to the restrictions introduced by the new police, crime sentencing and courts act.  Their combined effect will be to criminalise carrying a bike lock or superglue with intent, or making a loud noise, so heaven help anybody who sings as they cycle home from the DIY shop.

The right-wing has condemned some road-blocking demonstrations saying they delayed ambulances responding to emergencies, a claim the Ambulance Service has described as “farcical”.

It seems traditional Conservative values are still alive and kicking as Lee Anderson, a Tory MP, asked whether female representation in parliament would “increase or decrease” if Eddie Izzard were elected an MP and he told Talk TV he “would not follow him [sic] into the toilets”, presumably because he considers himself so devastatingly attractive that Izzard would be unable to keep her hands off him.  Izzard actually identifies as female and uses women’s lavatories, which means Anderson himself must habitually use ‘the Ladies’ if he’s worried about following Izzard in.

And in Jacob Rees-Mogg, the then business secretary, who saw the writing on the wall and resigned.  He then hopped up to the back benches and, when a fellow Conservative MP, Richard Graham, questioned the practicality of repealing and replacing more than 2,000 pieces of EU law within the next 14 months, accused him of refusing to accept Brexit, thereby totally missing the point. 

Rees-Mogg had been attempting to get the Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill enacted;  this would require the replacement of more than 2,000 laws covering almost everything from holiday pay rights to environmental protections to aircraft safety.  Luckily, it seems Sunak is likely to de-prioritise the Bill.

(Lawyers behind the original concept of EU-retained law have described the new Bill as “anti-democratic” and “completely barking”.)

Northern Ireland of course doesn’t even have a government in Stormont at the moment because the Democratic Unionist Party still refuse to share power with Sinn Féin who won more seats than they did.  I wonder which parts of ‘democracy’ and ‘union’ they don’t understand.

Germany is planning to legalise cannabis for recreational use while some UK politicians (none of whom, I’m sure, ever use nicotine or drink alcohol) are trying to get it reclassified as a Class A drug.  Wouldn’t it be more sensible for medical scientists to take an objective look at all drugs, including ‘natural’ and ‘processed’ ones, that are available legally or illegally (or only on prescription) and come up with a rather more sensible classification than the sledgehammer approach of the politically motivated Class A/B/C system?

The new Bond Street station on the Elizabeth line in London finally opened on Monday, four years and an estimated £570m over the original budget of £110m.  And that’s just one station.  Then try not to think of HS2 and restricted increases in state benefits.

We also heard that Salman Rushdie has lost his sight in one eye and the use of one hand after being stabbed about 15 times in the neck and chest at a lecture in New York in the summer.  I read ‘Midnight’s Children’ and enjoyed the first half but found the second half very heavy going and haven’t read any of his other books since.  It had won the Booker prize in 1981 and has been lauded ever since, which just goes to show what a philistine I am, but not why anybody should stick a knife in him even if he did subsequently write ‘Satanic Verses’ – it’s just another book.  I wish him well. 

Some students at Penn State university in America are protesting because Gavin McInnes, founder of the far-right group Proud Boys was invited to speak at a college meeting last week.  My immediate reaction was that anybody should be allowed to speak even if you disagree with what they might say.  Then I thought of the benefits arising from Donald Trump’s permanent ban from Twitter and wondered how open-minded I actually am, particularly since Elon Musk, Twitter’s new owner, is apparently considering reversing Trump’s ban. 

The number of people killed in clashes with police fell by more than half and the number of people resisting arrest fell by almost two thirds when police in the São Paulo state in Brazil were fitted with body cameras.  The far-right candidate who is the favourite to become São Paulo’s next governor, a Covid-denier, is talking about removing them to give the police more freedom of action.  Another idea for Trump here.

Did you know that, like lizards, some scorpions can shed their tails when attacked but, unlike lizards, their anuses are in their tails so they are doomed to die of constipation?  The researchers who discovered this were awarded the 2022 Ig Nobel prize in biology. 

And a smile.  The actor Bill Nighy is currently promoting ‘Living’ and, in one interview, said with dry self-deprecation that he’d gone alone to Paris when he was 17 “to write the great English short story”.  Well, it made me smile.

Biased facts, money management, green energy, HS2 and revenge killings

15 October 2022

Isn’t it strange how people who don’t hold the same views as you think anything you say is biased and counter them with their own biased views that they present as irrefutable facts?

John Cleese, the former comedian, has claimed he’d be immediately cancelled or censored by the BBC for saying what he then said, at some length, in a live, unedited broadcast interview on … er … the BBC.  Now he’s off to present a programme on GB News whose new chairman, Alan McCormick, dismisses the threat of climate breakdown and has claimed there is “no scientific proof” that humans have caused the climate emergency.

This insistence on believing what you want to in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary is behind the refusal of some Americans to admit that Donald Trump lost the presidency in 2020.  None of the facts suggest there’s any truth in this but Trump himself obviously encourages followers of his cult to believe that it’s the others who are wrong.

There must be the same sort of feeling over here after our new leaders, with less than a month’s experience in their posts, shocked the diehard Tory faithful by announcing an uncosted not-budget that was so idiotic not even Boris Johnson had thought of it.

The good news is that we are now seeing a succession of U-turns with a ‘not a windfall tax’ being imposed on energy companies by plans to cap their income on a cost-plus basis, possibly reversing the plan to link benefits to earnings rather than the cost of living, and there’s even talk of reversing the proposal to cut corporation tax (which brought Kwasi Kwarteng scuttling back from an International Monetary Fund gathering in Washington DC to be fired and replaced by the 4th chancellor in 4 months). 

Liz Truss said yesterday that they’d just underestimated international money markets’ reactions and she wouldn’t resign, leaving us to believe (a) she hadn’t supported Kwarteng’s not-budget but she’d let him go ahead anyway so the buck stopped with him rather than her and (b) she’ll be gone by Monday because there are no U’s left to turn. 

While this was all going on, Thérèse Coffey, the health secretary, was believed to be about to break a pledge to tackle smoking and its related health problems by raising the legal age to buy tobacco, licensing sellers, allocating extra money to discourage smokers, and possibly imposing levies on tobacco companies.  Guess whether she’s reported to be a smoker.

And Jacob Rees-Mogg is now the UK secretary of state for business, energy and industrial strategy.  He’s the man who’s admitted he was wrong to lie down on the government benches and, more recently gave us 7 months of total silence as Minister of State for Brexit Opportunities and Government Efficiency while the public accounts committee report, Regulating After EU Exit, reported that, almost two years after the UK Brexited, there are still shortages of vets, toxicologists, lawyers and economists.  (Perhaps the last three were intended as a joke.)

In his new job, he’s said that, while he’s not an admirer of Extinction Rebellion, he is in favour of a net zero future based on green energy and will accelerate the creation of more onshore and offshore wind farms.   However, he thinks it’d be “unconservative” to tell farmers how they should use their land but might realise he hasn’t thought this through when fields of cannabis plants and opium poppies appear in Kent, Peak District farmers build new towns and Devon woods and moorland are dug up and used as landfill sites.

In a similarly eccentric way, the new environment secretary Ranil Jayawardena thinks putting solar panels in fields will impede his programme of agricultural growth and increased food production (we’re apparently different from other countries where stock and crops thrive under raised panels which provide shade from the sun and shelter from the rain).  He’s asked for the assessment of the “best and most versatile” land to be rethought.  Land is currently graded from 1 to 5 and he wants 3a and 3b to be combined.  This just proves my theory that if you ask people to grade anything on a scale of 1 to 3, or 1 to 5, or 1 to 10, somebody will always mark something down by half a point.

Thursday’s headlines were fascinating:

  • “Truss faces mounting Tory pressure to rewrite unfunded tax-cut plans” (FT)
  • “Truss faces new peril as Tories go on the attack over economy” (Guardian)
  • “King Charles III’s Coronation: Row looms over crown for Camilla, Queen Consort” (Telegraph).

By this morning, even the Daily Telegraph couldn’t avoid the issue any more and the headlines were:

  • “Truss sacks Kwarteng in bid to save premiership” (FT)
  •  “A day of chaos” (Guardian)
  • “Truss clings to power after axing Kwarteng” (Telegraph).

The government’s reputation internationally was neatly summarised by the Washington Post who said “Truss … is still in office, but no longer in power”.

On the other side of the house, former shadow minister Sam Tarry has been removed from his seat by Labour members in his South Ilford constituency who voted instead to select the leader of Redbridge council, Jas Athwal, on Monday night.  Tarry’s sin was (according to an official Labour party comment) to say things that weren’t party policy in interviews when he joined a picket line in support of RMT workers.

Tarry is reportedly “in a relationship” with Angela Rayner, Labour’s deputy leader, which somehow doesn’t seem relevant.  Nor does the even more worrying implication that Labour ministers and MPs can only publicly spout stuff that’s “party policy” and aren’t allowed to have personal views that may be different.  Aren’t both Labour and the Conservatives supposed to be ‘broad churches’?  Don’t we tend to get better decisions from groups of people with different beliefs? 

At least Jeremy Hunt, this month’s chancellor of the exchequer, says changes need to be made and, after yet another broadcaster mispronounced his name, made a joke about it without getting upset; still, he must have got used to it over the years. 

Why not look again at HS2, whose lines seem to get shorter and have become more expensive and more delayed every time I look at it?  Lord (Tony) Berkeley left the government’s Oakervee review to write a dissenting account, saying that £147bn could be saved if the project were stopped now and a further £8bn could be recovered by shedding land it acquired for the project.

And in Ukraine, “the battle continued on” (from the final line of Suzanne Vega’s ‘The Queen and the Soldier’, one of the best anti-war stories ever sung). After Vladimir Putin’s new bridge between Crimea and Russia was damaged in an explosion, Putin assumed Ukraine did it and responded with murderous rocket attacks on Ukrainian civilians, saying “To leave such acts without a response is simply impossible.” 

Impossible?  Why?  Wouldn’t it have been better to accept it as collateral damage in a self-inflicted war and leave innocent civilians alive? 

Celebrations for a Grey Day

8 October 2022

As the Conservative party self-destructs, let’s look at the odd bits of cheering news that have surfaced recently.

The Institute of Fiscal Studies has calculated that the not-budget will give the richest households £2,290 more and the poorest £13 more, and Liz Truss has refused to raise the level at which we start to pay tax or to confirm benefits will be increased in line with inflation, thus making the poor poorer while the rich … er, no, hang on a minute, try again.

At the conference Truss wore a dress that appeared to be identical to the one worn by Emma Thompson in her role as Vivienne Rook, the fascist prime minister of the dystopian BBC drama ‘Years and Years’.  This comment has been criticised as an example of continuing misogyny in the media, except that the comment wasn’t about what she was wearing per se, it was about a comparison with a fictional fascist in a TV drama of which she might not even have been aware.

Anyway, The Woman in The Dress has reacted swiftly to allegations that one of her ministers was guilty of “serious misconduct” at last week’s Conservative party conference and has sacked him pending an investigation.  There’s a lesson for Boris Johnson there.

Encouraged, one suspects, by his lawyers, Elon Musk has U-turned again and reinstated his $44bn (£38bn) offer for Twitter.  Next, Musk will buy Tristan da Cunha, set it up as an international tax-avoidance state, build a rocket launching site and set up a company dedicated to denying the unreliability of Tesla cars.

Insulate Britain has gained a lot of media coverage with disruptive protests.  One of their spokespeople, Tracey Mallaghan, has said “I hate that to get media attention we have to disrupt lives.  But many people can see the sense in what we are asking for.”  One of my friends believes the demonstrators who blocked the M25 should be hanged drawn and quartered, regardless of the cause they were aiming to publicise;  others don’t.

George Kearsley Shaw (1751-1813), botanist and zoologist, founder of Linnean Society said: “The reasonable man [sic] adapts himself to the world;  the unreasonable man persists in trying to adapt the world to himself.  Therefore, all progress depends on the unreasonable man.”  (This argument could also, of course, be used to explain Truss’s apparent efforts to destroy the economy.)

For the first time in its history, the Royal College of Nurses, will ask its 300,000-strong membership if they want to strike, with the union encouraging them to vote yes.  If the strike goes ahead, the NHS will be severely disrupted this winter but which of us would deny their right to draw attention to how badly they (and the NHS as a whole) have been side-lined?

The day after Kwasi Kwarteng’s unfunded giveaways, the Bank of England stepped in to save a number of pension funds from going bust as the yields on long-term government bonds rocketed upwards.  What a good job we have a Bank of England and don’t just rely on the government.

The design of the new coins with the King’s head have been released and, as tradition demands, he faces in the opposite direction to his predecessor so we will have a King facing to the left.

In chess, there have been accusations that the 19-year-old, Hans Niemann has been cheating (he’s admitted to cheating in online games but denies cheating when playing in person) and one theory says anal beads were used.  Now I have to admit I don’t know what anal beads are or how they could help a chess player know which of 64,000 possible moves is the right one but I’m intrigued to know how anybody can sit still if something suddenly starts vibrating in their bum.

Since ‘we’ can remove the eye of a gnat with a missile fired from thousands of miles away and hit an asteroid with a multi-million dollar spacecraft travelling at 15,000 mph from millions of miles away, why can’t we find vaccinations that protect against cancer, circulatory problems, neurological conditions, mental health issues and indigestion here on earth?  Haven’t we got our priorities wrong?

Incidentally, what does 15,000 mph mean in space?  Speed is measured as relative to something else, like the ground over which a car is travelling.  So was this in relation to the asteroid it hit, or the earth (which was, by then, somewhere completely different) or alpha centauri?

Ondi Timoner, an American documentary film-maker, was shocked when her 92-year-old father Eli who had been paralyzed for 40 years by a stroke became bed-ridden and isolated by Covid and said he was “just waiting to die”.  With what was described as characteristic generosity and kindness, he gave his permission for her to record his last days and how his medically-assisted death affected his family. 

Ondi’s sister Rachel said of the film “I hope people get inspired to face the fact that they and everyone they love is going to die and if they have the courage to talk about it, and to plan for it a little bit, that they have a real chance to have a beautiful, good death.  And that that is a way for them to seize their lives.  It is a way for them to embrace their living.”  The film, ‘Last Flight Home’, is to be released in UK cinemas on 25 November. 

Vladimir Putin has said “We are working on the assumption that the situation in the new territories will stabilise”, thereby tacitly admitting the Russian losses caused by the Ukrainians’ fast and irresistible advance into occupied territory.  It reminded me of the Germans claiming in the (excellent) 1966 Czech film ‘Closely Observed Trains’:  “Our tactical retreat into Belgium has outpaced the Americans”.

In America, Joe Biden has pardoned thousands of people convicted of smoking a joint.  Nobody is actually in a federal prison for “simple possession” but the pardons correct the imbalance that has led to far fewer white smokers being convicted than people of colour despite skin colour not being an indicator of the prevalence of marijuana use.

And the Senate Republican leader, Mitch McConnell, has said he would “proudly support” legislation to overhaul rules for certifying presidential elections, bolstering a bipartisan effort to revise a 19th-century law and avoid any repeat of the January 6 insurrection, adding. “The chaos that came to a head on January 6 of last year certainly underscored the need for an update.”

In Iran, the mother of Nika Shahkarami, a 16-year-old who died after a demonstration over the death in custody of Mahsa Amini, a woman who had breached the strict Iranian dress code for women, has accused the authorities of trying to force her to lie and say her daughter killed herself.  Amini had been arrested by the morality police in Tehran.  The morality police???  George Orwell is turning in his grave.

TikTok’s latest craze (meme?) is for ‘brown noise’ is a sort of textured ‘white noise’ that relaxes people and turns off their thoughts.  A short trial didn’t work for me but I guess those of us who live with tinnitus are used to thinking over its endless interference.

A similar (but negative) effect on our senses is that, when we’re in REM/deep sleep, we don’t respond to smells, but they can influence whether our dreams are pleasant or less enjoyable.  Those of us who sleep near a recidivist farter (not me, I hasten to add, my wife would never dream of farting) should be duly grateful for this.

As people get richer and buy more ‘second homes’ in tourist areas and rent them out through Airbnb or to longer-term tenants, local communities crumble and house prices go up beyond the reach of the local people.  The Welsh government is planning to tackle this by raising discretionary council tax premiums for second homes by 300%, introducing a licensing scheme for holiday homes and generally tightening the regulations.  Vote Welsh!

UK’s financial suicide and Russian soldiers’ boots and tampons

1 October 2022

Wasn’t that fun!  A new broom has cleared out its own cupboards, and quite a lot more it had borrowed.  Not much in them for the poor and needy but what the hell, it’s the Tories.

John Crace of The Guardian has nicknamed the new chancellor Kamikwaze which seems particularly apposite as his budget has knocked the bottom out of various markets.  The only people who actually enjoyed last week (apart from the Labour party) are those who, with or without inside knowledge, short-sold sterling and made a mint as it hit an all-time low against the US dollar. Even though it recovered a few days later, Nomura, the Japanese bank, is still forecasting that the GBP/USD will reach parity before the end of the year (though some people have started calling sterling Shitcoin).

Confidence in the UK is also plummeting as interest rates rise and many mortgage lenders withdrew mortgage offers.  Some reckoned interest rates could rise to 6%, the Bank of England was forced into emergency action to help pension funds and the International Monetary Fund issued an unprecedented rebuke, telling the government to re-think the not-budget.

Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng have both reiterated their shared belief that their economic policy is on the right track and more tax cuts could be in the offing and the band played the last movement of Mozart’s piano sonata no. 2 in B-Flat Minor, Op. 35.  Except they had to meet the Office for Budget Responsibility to be told the truth, rather like being summoned to the headteacher’s study to hear why bullying younger pupils into rolling joints for you isn’t a good idea.

Paul Donovan, the chief economist at UBS global wealth management, said investors were inclined to see the Conservative party as a “doomsday cult”.

Then, on Thursday, Truss told listeners to BBC Radio Kent “We have taken action by … making sure that nobody is paying fuel bills of more than £2,500.”  Great!  We were paying more than that last year so either we’re going to get a reduction or she doesn’t know what she’s talking about.  I wonder which it could be.

It’s also widely believed that Truss appointed Mark Fullbrook as her chief of staff in return for a promise to let his lobbying company to run the Tories’ next general election campaign.  Seems strange to me that she feels she owes him for appointing him to an influential and well-paid job;  and she was paying him through his company to save him tax but has put him on the payroll since this was discovered.

The Labour party conference seemed to go well with new opinion polls putting them a record 33 points ahead at 54%, while the Tories’ only got 21%, Labour’s lead having doubled in only four days.  The conference opened with the national anthem, so I was expecting Kier Starmer to end it with the Hallelujah Chorus but that would probably have been a bit over the top.

Having already had three leaders, only one of them elected, in just over 3 years, the Tory party conference should be interesting.  Perhaps Truss will become the UK’s shortest-serving PM. 

There’s a Jeffrey Archer type novel in here:  LibDem member switches to Conservatives, slumbers quietly as a mole for years, grabs an opportunity, becomes leader, takes Conservative policies to extremes, brings down the government and destroys the party before her cover is blown and she’s welcomed back into the LibDems until vengeful Tories poison her muesli.

One can hope …

Might one also hope that Vladimir Putin is coming to the end of his term?  This week, he held what he called ‘referendums’ (why do I have a feeling the plural is ‘referenda’?  is it just I’ve forgotten my Latin?) in eastern Ukraine which allowed residents to decide whether they wanted to be part of Ukraine or Russia and, to make sure it was entirely fair, a heavily-armed Russian soldier stood outside each polling booth.  Followed by which he annexed various parts of Ukraine and was pictured singing a song with their leaders.  Curious how, while he can still open his mouth, no other part of face seems capable of movement.

A political commentator from the east described Russia last night as being like a dinosaur:  a huge body, a small head and a tiny brain.

Within Russia, there are some who don’t like what Putin’s doing while others support his attempts to recreate a Soviet republic;  just as there are those within Ukraine who want to stay Ukrainian while others would like to re-join Russia.  It’s all very complicated.

But protests continue as Russia enlists young and old, fit and frail, by counting arms and legs and passing everybody with two of each as fit for active service after an estimated 250,000 people have fled to Finland or Georgia to avoid the draft.

A friend’s sister has been keeping in touch with friends she made in Russia and Ukraine when she worked there for many years and has seen an unauthorised video of a female military medic instructing a bunch of new recruits.  In it, she tells them “You will get nothing except your uniforms, you must find everything else for yourselves. and you must have your own first aid kits. You need tourniquets.”  One says “There aren’t any in the pharmacies.”  She says ” Go through the first aid kits in your cars, ask relatives, I haven’t got enough for all of you! And ask your wives, mothers, girlfriends for sanitary pads and tampons, the cheapest, most basic, but get those too.”  “What for???” “It’ll be damp cold weather coming on, the pads as insoles help keep your feet dry inside your boots. And guess what the tampons are for?… for bullet wounds! Something I learnt in Chechnya. You push it into the wound, it swells and helps to stop the bleeding…”  (This video has apparently since gone viral.)

Our source’s comment was “This does demonstrate Russian resourcefulness in the most horrific circumstances. And the unreliability of Russian army boots.”

She also mentions one man who got a printed list headed “Essential Equipment for a Military Campaign” with his call-up papers that includes everything from a 60-litre rucksack, sleeping bag and mat, uniform and underwear and socks and boots, and seems to assume that recruits will have to provide these for themselves.  However, appeals are being made for citizens to give socks, underpants and cigarettes for the troops.  Cigarettes?  I’d take the spliffs rolled by the younger pupils – if you’re going to be cannon-fodder, you might as well die happy.

Further down the list are things like “a push-button phone with no contacts on it”, “a metal mug and spoon” and “provision pack for one day”.  More worryingly, “helmet” and “flak jacket” are on the list in bold type and marked as “DESIRABLE”.

Messages from the Ukrainian side are telling the new recruits to desert as soon as they can, promising them POW-status which will give them humane conditions and 3 meals a day.  Sounds good to me.

New president in waiting, Ukraine advances and Ig Nobel prizes

18 September 2022

We have a new prime minister who’s found herself leading a government neck deep in the muddy, with problems stretching from the cost of living crisis, energy costs, inflation, a looming recession, The Northern Ireland Brexit problem, strikes and the imminent collapse of the NHS to the climate crisis.

Sadly, she’s stuffed her new cabinet with her mates rather than the best people and is cancelling everything she can find, but at least Priti Patel’s gone before she can do any more damage to the UK’s reputation.

And she’s dumped Dominic Raab’s plans to restrict our human rights with a Bill that would have given the British government power to ignore rulings from the European Court of Human Rights.  (Raab had also been asked to include the right to abortion in the Bill but he said this was already “settled in UK law”, which isn’t actually true, but he’s gone as well.)

Other stuff she’s overturned so far is the ban on fracking until research into its vulnerability to earthquakes has been concluded – another 2019 manifesto pledge broken – and the cap on bankers’ bonuses.  She’s also promised an energy price freeze and cuts to tax and national insurance and refused to impose a windfall tax on energy companies. 

The Resolution Foundation estimate these “colossal” cuts will cost about £120bn but Liz Truss (aka The Faerie Feller) is planning a mini-budget this week which will explain where the money’s coming from. 

Her Master-Stroke was, on her first day in office, to alienate the entire civil service by firing Sir Tom Scholar, the highly experienced permanent secretary to the Treasury who, according to an inside source, was “viewed as one his generation’s outstanding civil servants [who] would loyally serve any new administration”.

Truss said the Treasury required “new leadership” to go with the new premiership and wanted to show how tough she is.  This will also encourage the waverers who were uncertain about her political history and thought she’s still a LibDem at heart but stood a better chance of becoming powerful as a Tory.  Her repeated U-turns also show her willingness to be competitive and beat Johnson’s record.

Some doubters believe that civil servants simply implement governmental decisions without any political fear or favour but Truss is clearly making a bold move towards politicising the civil service and pacifying the far right.  Their views were encapsulated by Lord (Robin) Butler, who served under Margaret Thatcher, John Major and Tony Blair.  He said “I think the politicians are beginning to forget the constitution. The civil service is Her [/His] Majesty’s civil service. A government wouldn’t come in and on the first day sack the head of Her Majesty’s defence forces.”

Truss also has the advantage of inheriting the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 which increases the powers of the police over things like peaceful demonstrations.  They’re certainly practising this in Edinburgh where a man in the crowds watching the royal procession was questioned for holding up a blank sheet of paper.  When he asked “What if I write ‘Not My King’ on it”, he was told he’d be arrested.

Great stuff PC Whoever, just what we need:  a strong police force supporting a strong civil service in thrall to a stupid strong leader.  Just a touch more gerrymandering might do the trick and we’ll have Tory governments forever.

Still, we must remember that Richard Dadd ended up in Broadmoor.

By the way, had you spotted that the same Police Act increases the maximum prison terms from 10 to 14 years for serious sexual assaults and to 10 years for assaulting a statue.  You only get four extra years inside for rape compared with throwing a tomato at a statue. 

A couple of weeks ago, Vladimir Putin reminded the world what brilliant a leader he is and said “We have not lost anything and will not lose anything”.  Followed by which Ukraine took the Russians entirely by surprise and have taken some 6,000 square kilometres of the Kharkiv region back under Ukrainian control.

Less cheering has been the discovery of graves marked just with a number outside Izium from which more than 440 bodies are being exhumed.  Close to these graves is an unmarked mass grave containing 17 Ukrainian soldiers.

In Iowa, a human trafficking victim, Pieper Lewis, killed the man who’d repeatedly raped her when she was 15 and being pimped for sex.  She pleaded guilty to manslaughter and wilful injury, each of which earned her a 10-year prison sentence.  A sympathetic district judge decided to defer the sentences on the grounds that the 834 days she had already spent in juvenile detention was enough “punishment” for a teenager and let her off with a 5-year probationary period.  

However, the judge also ordered her to pay $4,000 of state costs and the $150,000 restitution to the estate of the rapist that a state law demands of killers. 

The good news is that one of the woman’s former teachers, Leland Schipper, was so shocked she said “A child who was raped, under no circumstances, should owe the rapist’s family money” and set up a GoFundMe appeal that, as I write, has raised more than $540,000.  Schipper has said that the surplus will “remove financial barriers for Pieper in pursuing college/university or starting her own business [and] give Pieper the financial capacity to explore ways to help other young victims of sex crimes”.

Anybody else think Iowa needs to change the legislation to allow for exceptional cases?

And more good news from this year’s Ig Nobel awards, one of which was given to Prof Gen Matsuzaki who headed a Japanese team that researched the best way to turn a knob and concluded that the bigger the knob, the more fingers you need to turn it.  Other recipients studied how constipation affects the mating prospects of scorpions (cue old joke:  How do hedgehogs make love?  Very, very carefully.) and why success is due more to luck than to talent.  The last is blindingly obvious from a quick glance at the people who run our governments and companies but they proved it using mathematics (no, me neither).

For example, Southern Water’s Beachbuoy map showing which beaches they’ve polluted will no longer automatically include all raw sewage releases into bathing waters, thereby improving their record in one fell swoop.

And tomorrow the Queen’s funeral service will be attended by all foreign leaders who were invited and are willing to be bussed into London.  Except Joe Biden who’ll make his own arrangements thank you.  I’d love to be a fly inside the bus as foreign monarchs and presidents experience how the rest of us travel. 

Tax cuts, an honourable Republican, splitting parties, Thatcherism, water problems, and stupidity in Florida

21 August 2022

The two politicians vying to become Britain’s prime minister are both promising tax cuts despite having PPE degrees.  I always though the E stood for ‘economics’ but apparently it stands for ‘eejits’.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (a non-political organisation specialising in the effects of economic and fiscal policies) has pointed out that an increase of 10% in the cost of living (five times what it was this time last year) will cost the government more on pensions and state benefits and increasing interest rates will increase the cost of debt interest.

Rishi Sunak has said he will cut taxes, but only after inflation has come down again, while Liz Truss is planning to cut taxes regardless.

But she has a history of inconsistency and, in a co-authored 2012 book (Britannia Unchained), she described British workers as being among the “worst idlers in the world” and that they need “more graft” and lack the “skill and application” of foreign rivals. 

As a self-confessed ‘patriot’, she’s also suggested the north south divide is “partly a mindset or attitude thing”.  Brilliant!

But she still seems to be the front-runner so she could provide easy meat for the Labour party to masticate at PMQs, if they can get their act together. 

America proved that some Republicans’ hearts are in the right places as Liz Cheney sacrificed her seat in Congress to her principles.  Wyoming is staunchly Republican but has been divided by Donald Trump’s attempts to disunite the States. 

Having lost to a conservative Trumpist lawyer, Harriet Hageman, who supports Trump’s claims that he is America’s true president, Cheney said “Two years ago, I won this primary with 73% of the vote … but [repeating this] would have required … that I enabled [Trump’s] ongoing efforts to unravel our democratic system and attack the foundations of our republic.”

She’s since admitted she’s considering running for president in 2024 and has said she will “do whatever it takes to keep Donald Trump out of the Oval Office”.

Perhaps America should split into 4 parties:  the gun-toting, anti-abortion far right, ‘traditional’ Republicans, ‘traditional’ Democrats and soft-centred socialists?

Our own dear Conservative party is also becoming more divided, with some still believing that Maggie Thatcher said, “there’s no such thing as society”.  What she actually said was “I think we have gone through a period when too many children and people have been given to understand ‘I have a problem, it is the Government’s job to cope with it!’ … so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first.”

Some cynics believe that she only became prime minister in 1975 because she was more obviously not Ted Heath than the other candidates.  Curious that the Tories are now desperate to find somebody who is obviously not Boris Johnson.  I wonder why they don’t pick the right person first time?

Thatcher was proud of being a grocer’s daughter but suffered from tunnel-vision which inspired her to think people should look after themselves first and she made it clear that she didn’t think it was the government’s job to help people cope with problems.  This was, of course, only some 30 years after a (admittedly Labour) government had introduced the National Health Service which was free to everyone and the state had taken over responsibility for other public services such as transport and mining.

Thatcher believed that individuals would do things better and more cheaply than the state could so she created ‘Thatcherism’ which starts from the sadly erroneous belief that people would do things better if they operated in a free market with minimum state interference.

What she failed to take into account is that public companies aren’t run by the owners any more than state services were run by the civil service.  Both models are run by people who work for the organisations and the ‘owners’ (whether company shareholders or civil servants) don’t make operating decisions.

She started the privatisation programme by selling half the ‘ownership’ of British Telecoms at a discount, in the vain hope that it would end up owned by its individual customers who would have a vested interest in its operations and take care of it.  There was lots of publicity for the sale and lots of people bought shares.  The share price immediately shot up and many of the new owner/shareholders immediately took advantage of the free market and sold their shares at a nice profit.  Despite this, the government sold its remaining shares in 1991 and 1993 and now one shareholder, Patrick Drahi of the Altice telecom group, owns 18% of BT.

Subsequent governments, including Labour governments, continued to flog off increasingly unlikely services with entirely predictable results.

All but one (British Gas) of the big six energy companies that supply 60% of the UK’s energy are state-owned again, but by other European countries, not Britain, and they use the profits they make from supplying British energy to support their own energy companies. 

Breaking up and selling off the railways to the highest bidders didn’t work either.  Since the initial sales, three train operating companies have been renationalised, others have surrendered their contracts and 14 are wholly or partly state-owned by France, Germany, the Netherlands, Italy or Hong Kong.

You couldn’t make it up.

I’d always assumed that, when selling public transport operations, the government specified the routes and frequency of services to be run and limited ticket price increases but I was obviously over-optimistic about the competence of the governments involved because Avanti has recently cut 2/3 of its services between London and Manchester and local ‘unprofitable’ bus services are being re-routed and cut.  Surely the contract can’t have guaranteed profit margins rather than the services to be run? 

The privatised companies attracting most flak this month are the water companies who agree with the provisional estimate of Ofwat, their ‘regulator’, that they lost more than 1,000,000,000,000 litres of water through leaks last year.  That’s enough to fill Lake Windermere, the largest (but not the deepest) body of fresh water in England and Wales, three and a half times.

Of course many waterpipes are still Victorian but the total water lost hasn’t been reduced significantly this century despite the companies’ undertakings to mend the leaks.

This year’s drought means that the reservoirs we still have are at their lowest-ever levels and rivers are drying up, with some of them probably kept flowing only by the foul water and farming run-off that is squirted into them.  Southern Water was fined £90m for dumping raw sewage straight into the sea and recent heavy rainstorms have led to warnings not to enter the sea on many of southern England’s most popular beaches.

Since 1990, Britain’s population has increased by about 20% (an extra 10m people) and several major water companies have sold reservoirs to make money and/or build new houses.  The creation of only one new reservoir, near Southampton, has been approved. 

Since they were privatised, the water companies have paid more than £70bn to their shareholders in dividends and their directors and top management paid themselves £25m in the year 2021/22.  Thames Water gave its executives £3m just in bonuses last year, despite their having been repeatedly criticised for failing to repair leaks; they’re now introducing a hosepipe ban.

The Environment Agency recently called for water company bosses to be jailed for serious pollution, after finding the water firms’ performance on pollution was the worst seen in years but, since it costs £40,000 a year to keep someone in prison, make them pay the fines personally, debar them from future directorships, and sentence them to community service.

England and Wales are the only countries in the world to have full privatised their water companies – and you can see why!  Scottish water, which is still publicly-owned, spent more than 35% more per household on infrastructure than those companies south of the border.

And a court in Florida has decided that a 16-year-old isn’t “sufficiently mature” to have an abortion but is mature enough to carry and give birth to and nurture a baby.

Next week:  is there intelligent life on earth?

By-elections, Boris’s triumphs, more greedy pigs, Afghanistan, guns and choosing clothes

26 June 2022

The Tories were trashed at both this week’s by-elections.  Crocodiles are weeping salt tears all over the land.

Oliver Dowden, chair of the Conservative Party resigned saying “Somebody must take responsibility” in a carefully worded statement emphasising his continuing support for the party, leaving us to guess who doesn’t have his continuing support.

It’s actually hard to believe that so many Conservative voters changed their party allegiance;  it’s much easier to believe that many die-hard Tories have finally had to accept that Boris Johnson is the UK’s worst prime minister in living memory and it’s time for him to go.  (I’m sure that, by the time you read this, he’ll have accepted responsibility and stepped aside.  Not.)

My Conservative friend said on Friday he hadn’t yet “analysed the figures but I am pretty certain that in Wakefield, the turnout was low and the swing largely attributable to people not voting.”  He said he was disappointed that the winners attributed their victories to Johnson than to their parties’ policies and he “would have preferred it if more Tories had voted.”

He also doubts if Johnson will go and thinks he will lead the Conservatives into the next election and, unless the various opposition parties can get their act together, will win it.

One has to admire his unquestioning optimism in the face of party grandees urging Johnson to step down but those of us who believe the ‘Boris-effect’ did influence Thursday’s results are hoping his optimism is justified.

Politically, the two of us are on the opposite sides of the governmental midden, but he’s obviously upwind of it.

Johnson himself was in Ruanda at the time to prove that, given 4-deep security cover, the country is tremendously safe for people the UK doesn’t want living here. 

This week, he refused to deny having tried to get Carrie Symonds, who is now his wife, a job in the FCDO when he was Foreign Secretary and still married to Marina Wheeler and he’s now threatening to stay for a third term.

I mean, look at all his earlier triumphs.  Their happened to be some clever scientists in the UK who were first with an effective covid vaccine, which allowed Johnson to claim credit for this even though he’d caused an estimated 10,000 deaths by delaying the first lockdown until (quite coincidentally he has assured us) after his wife’s baby shower. 

And “We got Brexit done” he says.  What a man!  Apart from the problems caused in Northern Ireland, the disruption and delays at other borders and the extra paperwork, increases in the costs of shopping and fuels, lying to the queen about the legality of proroguing parliament, and being fined for breaking his own laws, he’s clearly the right man to destroy the UK’s international reputation;  and what a brilliant job he’s making of it.

The Daily Telegraph really did do well this week by getting its website blocked by Russia for “disseminating false information about a special military operation by the Russian armed forces in Ukraine”.  On 23 February, the day before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, it published a report on Russia’s use of “mobile crematoriums” (crematoria?) that can incinerate troops killed in wars – sorry, special military operations – to conceal the number of soldiers killed.  “Ivan Ivanovich?  Nah, sorry missus, never ‘eard of ‘im”.

The consumer price index showed that annual inflation approached 10% in May, its highest level for 40 years and the highest in the G7 group of wealthy nations.  We’re lucky enough not to be scraping the bottom of the barrel yet but our usual milk has gone up from £1.15 at the beginning of the year to £1.45 now, which seems a bit excessive.  Perhaps we should all be buying supermarket shares since I’m sure their directors and shareholders won’t be sharing the pain.  

Which inevitably leads to this week’s Greedy Pig awards:  Simon Arora, chief executive of B&M who was given £5m last year, 270 times the pay of the average worker.  Despite B&M’s having a market capitalisation only ¼ that of Tesco, Arora got more than the £4.75 given to Ken Murphy, his oppo at Tesco (who also qualifies for an award).

What’s wrong with these people?

Independent experts, the Pay Review Body, are recommending that NHS workers should receive a pay rise of 4-5%;  the government has said they can only afford 3% and any more would break the bank.    Their message is clear:  money is more important than you and me. 

What’s wrong with these people?

In Afghanistan, the Taliban are appealing for international aid following at least two devastating earthquakes which have killed hundreds.  Should we ignore their appeals because Taliban men are really horrible, or should we help them because the people who are most affected are just ordinary people?

The week’s most devastating (but unsurprising) news was America’s Supreme Court overturning Roe v Wade.  Although Americans may still consider themselves ‘free’, just six people (5 men and 1 sort-of-woman, all muppet Republicans, two of whom had recently said they would not vote against the precedent set by this case) ignored the wishes of 75% of the population and removed the right to choose abortion from the country’s 170 million women.

They also over-ruled a New York law that had, since the early 1900s, required people to demonstrate a need before they can get a licence to own a gun before they can carry one in public places …

What’s wrong with these people?

However, the Senate did approve a bill that goes some way towards curbing the licensing and sale of guns.  Softly softly catchy monkey?

Ukraine is withdrawing its troops from Sievierodonetsk, leaving Lysychansk the only city in the Luhansk region of the Donbas area still in Ukrainian control but its formal application to join the EU has been accepted.  The EU isn’t NATO of course but it’ll be interesting to see Vladimir Putin’s response in the light of the rumours that Russia’s lost very large numbers of troops and equipment.

There are reports that small groups of Ukrainian military are creeping into Russian-occupied areas and stealing their tanks.  Isn’t that wonderful!

Even more enchanting is an article I read recently on how fashionistas choose what they’re going to wear each day.  Some people decide the night before, others choose their footwear in the morning by the shape of their trouser (“A darker, slimmer leg calls for a more streamlined sneaker, whereas a wider pant in a lighter shade might match back well with a tan sandal or loafer.”)  Others start with a single piece of clothing and build everything else around it or “intuitively” choose colours that they feel suit the energy of the day, while others choose them by mood.

My wife and I once saw Karl Lagerfeld (well, she recognised him but then had to tell me who he was) in a shop in Paris.  He’d probably made a conscious decision about what to wear that day but he looked a right prat.

Nobody asked me how I choose what to wear each day.  After doing the washing, I put clean smalls in the back of the drawer and shirts on one end of a rack.  Then, in the morning, I take smalls from the front of the drawer and a shirt from the other end of the rack.  I don’t even have to turn on the light.  Footwear and outerwear depend on the weather but I’m generally barefoot in the house and garden when it’s warm. 

Some people would no doubt say this accounts for a lot about me but that’s their problem not mine.

There was a puzzling report from China this week that two people were killed when a Nio electric car, being developed in China as a potential rival to Tesla, fell from the third floor of an office in Shanghai.  The report details of various reactions to the crash, including a defensive statement from the manufacturer saying the accident was “not caused by the vehicle itself” (i.e.  it wasn’t the first recorded case of AI suicide) but the version I saw entirely failed to explain the obvious question:  how did it get up the stairs?

Guns, diluting standards, Elizabeth line and typos

29 May 2022

19 young children and two primary school teachers have been shot dead, and three more young children orphaned when the husband of one of the dead teachers had a heart attack two days later.

The murderer was a teenager who wasn’t old enough to buy alcohol but had legally bought and registered two automatic weapons, practised by shooting his grandmother.

This was at Uvalde’s Robb elementary school in south west Texas, 10 days after another teenager had killed 11 people at a supermarket in Buffalo NY.

The school itself is said to have established and practised safety responses – locking the door, turning the lights out, hiding under desks and everybody staying very quiet – but this wasn’t enough.

Gun violence is of course endemic in America and, while a small majority of people believe gun laws should be tightened, the National Rifle Association spent almost $5m last year trying to convince people they are already too restrictive.  It’s also, of course, complicated by the lack of any federal law which restricts everyone, so states make their own laws.

In the UK, a murderer shot a lot of children at a primary school in Dunblane in 1996.  In 1997, the successive Conservative and Labour governments under John Major and Tony Blair passed a law banning the private ownership of handguns despite active opposition from the gun lobby and many on the political right (including one Boris Johnson) who argued that owning guns wasn’t the problem, even though the one thing that all such killers have in common is they own a gun.

Since then, gun crime in Britain has fallen significantly, fatal shootings are mercifully rare and these have almost all been individually targeted rather than mass murders.

International comparisons also show that the more households that have guns, the more gun-related deaths there are, and records of shootings in America show that having a gun in the house actually makes it more likely that a member of the household will be killed by one.

The laws vary widely between different American states, from Massachusetts where gun ownership is fairly tightly controlled (by American standards) to Texas where there are few controls.   Many who support gun ownership quote the Second Amendment to the US Constitution but others argue that these people either haven’t actually read the amendment or failed to understand its purpose and that the ‘founding fathers’ of the United States would be horrified to see how their intentions are being misinterpreted.

Just as worrying is the lack of any control on the sale of ammunition.  In a recent documentary, a British journalist asked one dealer how much ammunition he could buy.  The answer was “How much money have you got?”

I wonder how many gun owners are male and how many female.  My own prejudices make me feel that you’re more likely to see a man with a big penis-substitute in a holster than a woman with a Saturday night special in her handbag, but I could be entirely wrong.

The trouble is that the problem has been linked – probably by the NRA – with politics so, broadly speaking, Democrats want more gun control while Republicans want more guns.  The gun lobby thinks the answer is more guns, and teachers should be armed so that, if a gunman (I’m sticking with the sexism) enters their classroom, the children can watch a real-life shooting match in which real people get hurt and killed.

Their argument is that guns aren’t dangerous, it’s people with guns that are dangerous but ignores the fact that the country has conspicuously failed to educate gun owners so far.

Other suggestions include

  • incorporating the NRA’s safety rules in federal law
  • banning automatic weapons and extended magazines
  • perhaps even allowing only guns that fire just one bullet before they need to be reloaded
  • limiting gun permits to hunters
  • increasing the minimum age for gun ownership to 21
  • more background checks, including mental health histories
  • requiring a gun permit when selling ammunition and only selling cartridges for the gun in the permit
  • limiting the amount of ammunition that can be sold to any one person
  • requiring owners to be insured and responsible for all damage caused by a gun registered in their name
  • rewriting the second amendment to make it clear that “a well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State” is the prime reason for “the right to keep and bear Arms”.

Jacinda Ardern gave Harvard’s annual commencement address this week and was given a standing ovation after describing how New Zealand had tightened gun laws after the 2019 shootings in the Christchurch mosque.

Let’s hope Americans have the courage to make changes.  

The UK can do it: Boris Johnson rewrote the rules on Friday to remove the duty of ministers to resign after breaching the code of conduct and deleted the words “honesty”, “integrity”, “transparency” and “accountability” from the foreword, thereby exempting ministers from four of the seven (Nolan) principles of public life (adopted in 1995).  All this in an attempt to save the skin of a congenital liar who probably can’t even spell integrity and who believes being open about and accountable for one’s actions are for lesser people from cheaper schools.

The good news is that, after five months of pressure from the Labour party to introduce windfall taxes on serendipitous profits, the chancellor of the exchequer, Rishi Sunak, has finally accepted they are necessary and done a U-turn, though actually he’s not imposing ‘windfall taxes’, he’s imposing a “temporary targeted energy profits levy” which is, of course, quite different.

Anything to divert attention from the details in Sue Gray’s report on ‘partygate’.

And, in another amazing coincidence, this week saw Johnson claiming credit for the opening of nearly all of the short central section of London’s Elizabeth line which was described by one commentator as being “true to the finest traditions of British infrastructure … years over deadline and billions above budget”.

I can remember Crossrail’s route being discussed in the early 1990s and, after years of negotiations, building work officially started in 2009.  While this was shortly after Johnson had been elected mayor of London, claiming credit for it seems to be rather less than truthful – good job he’s no longer required to be honest.

The only real success in the story is that some 3m tonnes of soil dug out from under London was taken to Wallasea Island on the Essex coast, creating a new wetland sanctuary for birds.

Back in the days of typesetters and hot lead, the Guardian contained so many typographical errors that Private Eye always referred to it as the Grauniad but the editors always took it in good spirit and apologised when necessary.  A columnist in yesterday’s paper repeated what she described as “the greatest correction of all time”:

“A caption in Guardian Weekend, page 102, November 13, read ‘Binch of crappy travel mags’.  That should, of course, have been ‘bunch’.  But more to the point, it should not have been there at all.  It was a dummy which we failed to replace with the real caption.  It was not meant to be a comment on perfectly good travel brochures.  Apologies.”

And the week’s other major event was Bob Dylan’s 81st birthday.  Never let anyone tell you that excessive use of drugs will shorten your life.

Wealth distribution, the Robin Hood Solution, FatCat awards and a kindness

22 May 2022

Half of England is owned by less than 1% of the people who live here.  If the land were distributed equally between us, everybody would have an acre (0.4 hectares) to themselves.

Of course this is oversimplistic since not everybody would want to live in Much Piddling in the Marsh, or on top of Scafell Pike, but it does show just how unbalanced life has become.

North of the border, a study by the Scottish Land Commission found that 4.2m acres (1.7m hectares) has just 87 owners and that another 6m acres (2.4m hectares) was owned by 1,038 owners, including ‘OK’ owners such as the National Trust for Scotland (a charity) and Scottish government bodies.

Three of the largest landowners in Scotland are the Danish clothing billionaire, Anders Povlsen, and his wife Anne, the Duke of Buccleuch (pronounced B’kloo and not like somebody trying to be sick, but I’m sure you knew that) and the Church of … er …  England.  The Povlsens are re-wilding their land and invest a lot in facilities for local communities.

The C of E and Buccleuch both see land as an investment and the Church has converted large areas of farmland into commercial conifer plantations that make money for them and sterilise the land underneath.  Buccleuch is selling a large parcel of grouse moor in Dumfries and Galloway and is asking an extremely high price for hills with lots of SSSI restrictions that can’t be covered with large forests or windfarms.  A community project, the Langholme Initiative, would like to buy the land to conserve its wildlife, woodland and peatlands but is having difficulty raising the money Buccleuch wants.

Sadly, rather than working together towards some sort of joint enterprise, the Buccleuch estate has said “We are a rural business and any sale of any property goes to reinvesting in other projects which create jobs and helps the rural economy”, the clear implication being that their “business” of helping the rural economy (i.e.  making money for the Duke and his family) would be hampered by the involvement of an actual local community-based project whose aim is to “restore globally important peatlands and ancient woods, establish new native woodlands and ensure a vital haven for iconic wildlife” on the estate.

We’re seeing the same imbalance in government with the government trying to concentrate more and more power in the hands of the unqualified and unworthy few.

We’re seeing them propose that politicians should be able to over-rule the Supreme Court of judges with vast legal knowledge and experience. We’re seeing them criminalising peaceful demonstrations.  We’re seeing Priti Patel, the home secretary, trying to interfere in local policing.  We’re seeing Rishi Sunak, chancellor of the exchequer, and his wife appear in the Sunday Times ‘rich list’. And we’re seeing Boris Johnson propose “levelling up”.  I can’t see how they can possibly begin to understand how poor some people are, and how they really do have to choose between heating and eating, and that some actually can’t afford to do either.

In any event, “levelling up” is, of course, an oxymoron and can never be achieved.  Since the Conservatives would never talk about ‘levelling down’ it’s just one of those meaningless phrases that are so useful for people who are too stupid to put action before words.  Think about it.  When everybody has been levelled up, we’d all be worth the same as the Sunaks and there’d be nothing to spend the money on because nobody would have to work or do Brexit-inspired paperwork.

Here’s a practical and workable alternative:  the Robin Hood Solution.

Charles Dickens had Micawber say “Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery.”  This is, course true for individuals at a personal level but, at some point, it got extrapolated to national levels and Maggie Thatcher, born of small shopkeeper stock, had it engraved on her heart.  Because she got a 2 for 1 offer, she had it written on George Osborne’s heart as well, and look at the damage they both did.

The proof can be seen in the Conservatives’ belief that people shouldn’t ask for pay rises while the cost of living overtakes and drowns them.  (This naturally doesn’t apply to people who effectively decide for themselves what they’ll be paid – see this week’s FatCat awards below.)

Rishi Sunak briefly saw the light as the coronavirus pandemic started:  “whatever it takes,” he said and poured billions into anti-virus efforts.  Good for him.  But he (and most politicians on both sides of the house) still cling to the belief that countries must balance their books.

We have to get things in proportion and accept that giving billions away in an economy worth trillions is irrelevant.

It’s not helped by the UK’s tax system having become utterly unfit for purpose.  For the sake of simplicity, let’s just take income tax and keep the existing structure so the change could be made very quickly.  Here’s a suggestion:

  • link the personal allowance (the amount everyone can get before they pay any tax) to the national living wage – just over £18,000 as I write – which would take a lot of people out of the tax system entirely
  • if their income (from all sources) is more than this, their tax rate would on the next tranche as their income increased (a principle that’s already established), perhaps as follows:
    • up to £18,000: no tax payable
    • £18,000 – £30,000:  10%
    • £30,000 – £50,000:  20%
    • £50,000 – £150,000:  40%
    • £150,000 – £250,000:  60%
    • then further increases up to £500,000 when a top rate of 120% would apply.

These suggested bands would result in people getting less than £30,000 paying less tax, those getting £30,000-£150,000 would pay the same, and those getting more than £150,000 paying more. 

The most important thing is the top rate, which should be more than 100%.  The principle is obvious:  anybody getting more than £500,000 would have to pay the excess straight back to HMRC and top it up from their personal capital, which wouldn’t half make big businesses think.

For example, using these figures, somebody with income of £145,000 would take home £42,800 while somebody with income of £155,000 would take home £40,800, £2,000 less.

(Income from overseas could be taxed in full at UK rates and the people concerned would be allowed to reclaim any tax paid twice from the other countries – there’s generous!)

National Insurance rates, benefits in kind, pensions and VAT could be similarly rethought, but this would be a start.

Windfall taxes would be imposed automatically on all companies who rip off their customers rather than return windfall (unearned) profits to them (which, according to The Times, our government has described as ‘ideologically unconservative’).

Think of higher education which is increasingly available only to students whose families can afford it and students graduate believing it’s OK to have debts (on which some of them are soon likely to be paying 12% interest!)   If the only criterion were ability, we would get better quality graduates and we wouldn’t end up with the cabinet we now have …

The money raised would of course be used to restore state funding for public services such as the NHS, education, local authorities, police, state benefits and social care and housing* back to the updated value of what they got in 2010. 

Which inevitably leads to this week’s Fat Cat / Greedy Pig awards which go to Ben van Beurden, chief executive of Shell, who was given £13.5m;  Simon Wolfson, Next’s chief executive (£4.4m);  and Andy Hornby, chief executive of the Restaurant Group (£1.2m, up from £518,000 in the previous year if the AGM approves it next week).

And finally, some kindness.  In 1999, a 12-year old and her 17-year old sister were on a flight to America, both of them refugees fleeing from the war-torn former Yugoslavia, when a woman gave them an envelope and made them promise not to open it till they were on the ground again.  Inside was a pair of earrings, a $100 bill and a short note, just signed Tracy.

The girl kept the envelope and has spent the last decade trying to find Tracy to say thank you and tell her what a difference it made to them, and how it’s still shaping their lives 23 years on.

*          Can anybody explain to me how a government that accepts the need for more social and ”affordable” housing reconciles this with their plans to reduce social and ”affordable” housing stock by selling it to occupiers at discounted prices?

2 DVLA cock-ups, another government disaster and a capitalist admits breaking the law for money

27 March 2022

I’ve been driving an untaxed car!  I discovered this recently when I thought it was due an MoT so I decided to check the log book, only to discover I hadn’t got one.  So I filled in a form and sent it to DVLA with the slip headed “Do not sent this to DVLA” they requested and a log book arrived remarkably quickly – or, if you add in the two years since we bought the car, remarkably slowly.

I also decided to check when the road tax was due so I went online and found it was due on 1 January last year.  Heigh ho, I thought, and got to the payment page which would only let me tax it from 1 January this year, which I did.  Before some genius did away with them, you could look at the disc in the windscreen to see when your tax expired.  (No wonder the police say there are now so many more untaxed cars on the roads.)

The obvious thing to do then was to tell the police what had happened so I emailed them and told them the whole story in glorious technicolour.  The following day, I had a very helpful call from the police saying not to worry, I’d done all the right things and no action would be taken against me.

We also have another ‘car’ that’s been adapted so my wife can drive her wheelchair up a ramp into it and, last week, we actually had a tax reminder letter from DVLA.  Sadly, it was headed, in bright red letters, “Last chance”, saying “Tax it or lose it, we can always spot an untaxed car”, which was entirely misleading.  To somebody who, as a point of principle, pays bills on the day they’re received, the most irritating thing was the “Last chance” threat which should have read “first chance, reminder and last chance combined” and explained that they’re saving the planet by only sending a single reminder 6 weeks after the tax expires.

They also said they can take the car away because they can always spot an untaxed car.  Yes but.  In the other car, I must have passed hundreds of Automatic Number Plate Recognition cameras which would have registered the fact that it wasn’t taxed and I’ll leave you to guess how many letters, emails, phone calls, police tow-away trucks or threats of court action we’ve seen and how many times I’ve been stopped by Highway Patrols on motorways.

But my new passport arrived safely so I now have alternative photo ID to my driving licence.   I never used to care about my passport, though I was quite proud of my expired plum-coloured EU passports that allowed me travel all over Europe without having to queue with other aliens at borders.  My new passport is blue and has “British Passport” written across the top.  I find I’m now feeling ashamed to be so publicly identified as British and will have to attempt to talk French with a New Zealand accent next time we’re in France.

Vladimir Putin continues to lay waste to a country he thinks should be part of ‘his’ Russia.  Surely, if he really did believe Ukraine should be part of Russia, wouldn’t he want to keep it as pristine and complete as possible?

In China, the Carter Centre’s US-China Perception Monitor published a suggestion by Hu Wei, a Shanghai scholar, that China should sever its links with Putin.  This received over a million views but was swiftly rejected by the Chinese authorities and the author and the publisher’s websites were blocked in China.  In essence, the translation I saw said “China should avoid playing both sides in the same boat, give up being neutral, and choose the mainstream position in the world.”  While the sentiment is clear, let’s hope the translator is now taking lessons in English metaphors and their use.

The penultimate turf was laid on last week’s grave by the unrepentant extremist greedy bastard capitalist Peter Hebblethwaite, the boss of P&O, after he’d fired 800 UK staff without notice.  When asked on Thursday by an incredulous Darren Jones, chair of the Commons business committee, “Are you in this mess because you don’t know what you’re doing, or are you just a shameless criminal?”, Hebblethwaite told the committee that he had “absolutely no doubt we were required to consult with the unions. We chose not to do that.”

He later apologised and said “we will compensate everyone in full” but “I would make this decision again, I’m afraid.”  The replacement crew will receive an hourly rate starting at £5.15, except on the Larne-Cairnryan route between Northern Ireland and Scotland, where it’s bound by UK law.

Hebblethwaite told MPs he was “saving the business”.  He admitted he was paid £325,000 a year (approximately £1,500 per working hour) plus two bonuses.  New crew members working in international waters that aren’t subject to the UK minimum wage, would be paid £5.15 per working hour.  Hebblethwaite didn’t answer when asked if he could live on £5.15 an hour.  Arrogant pig.

The final turf was laid on last week’s grave by the Chancellor of the Exchequer who cut fuel duty by enough to take its cost back to last week’s level (if garages pass the cut on to customers), raised the threshold for making national insurance contributions and said that the basic rate of income tax would be cut by 1p but not until just before the next election in two years’ time (coincidence that, eh?)

I have two friends whose gain from the billionaire’s husband’s budget is that fuel will only cost 25% more than this time last year but heating will still be 3 or 4 times as much.  Neither of them pays NIC because one is retired and the other is an unemployed single parent of a 4-year old and has to scrape by on benefits, which will only increase by half the current rate of inflation.  It seems that both are too low in the heap for governments to care about.

I realise people voted Conservative because they wanted a Conservative government to favour the rich and make the poor pay for it but I can’t begin to understand how society decayed so badly so fast.  Shouldn’t we, however we vote, support those less fortunate than ourselves and, if that means taking money from those who have too much, so what?

Having vented my spleen on the evening of the budget, I was somewhat comforted to see that even the right-wing press felt his budget had blown Rishi Sunak’s credibility.  ‘Levelling up’ didn’t last long did it?

But what can we ‘normal’ people do?  Our answer is to do our best to help individuals and support charity appeals for things like the victims of Putin’s war; and pin a Ukrainian flag to our fence.

The only cheering things last week was Nazanin Zaghira-Ratcliffe’s press conference at which she slammed the government’s failures – six years, five foreign secretaries, how many does it take, she asked.  This led to a horrific outpouring of bile from people who thought she should be grateful it had only taken six years and five foreign secretaries, including at least one sexist misogynist, probably on the far right, who accused her of disloyalty to her husband because he had just thanked the government for getting her out.  Men who imagine women should be subservient still seem to exist – I wonder if you could slip a pill for that into their beer.

Another person summarised the problem rather neatly by tweeting “She doesn’t owe us gratitude: we owe her an explanation” but, sadly, this noble sentiment was rather undermined by the tweeter himself, who was Jeremy Hunt, one of the foreign secretaries who had failed to bring her home.